Last week, my partner and I performed a familiar ritual of modern co-parenting: I told him that I felt overburdened by mental labor, and we made a plan to adjust. The logistical work of managing our kids’ lives has recently ramped up steeply, and while we’d been sharing the hands-on work equally, a lot of the ramping up had fallen into the category of family managerial work that can get out of whack without anyone meaning to shirk or to let-shirk. The challenge, of course, is that managing and feeling responsible are often invisible. But there’s more to it than that: You could easily miss that you’re not doing a full half of the managing and feeling responsible because even without doing a full half, you are still doing a lot of managing and feeling responsible! There’s just so much to think about, keep track of, and hope to avoid fucking up. It’s a challenge for even two earnest people to tend to it all with enough time left over to just enjoy the adventure of living with and raising kids.
A timely moment, then, for me to stumble upon this article asking “Can A.I. Apps Be a Mom’s Second Brain?” (I think that should be a free link.) It opens like this:
‘One recent evening, Lisa Green’s 5-year-old son, Fitz, came home from school bummed. He couldn’t check out a book from the school library because he hadn’t yet returned his last book.
His mother, a 34-year-old medical resident in pediatrics, said the family…hadn’t realized that books were due on different days each week in accordance with a rotating printed schedule that Fitz had brought home from kindergarten.
As a solution, she located the schedule, took a picture and uploaded it to an artificial intelligence agent named Ollie. Now, Green gets a text message reminding her to pack Fitz’s library book before it is due.
“I was at the point where all the balls I’m starting to drop feel like the glass ones,” Green said, “and that was kind of a breaking point for me.”’
The article goes on to describe how “families have turned to [A.I.] to manage the spiraling administrative tasks that make up much of modern parenthood.”
Some preliminaries: First, the mom framing is annoying. Second, this whole cognitive labor of parenting should probably ideally be treated as a structural problem with a structural solution. For those who won’t read the whole thing, neither of these observations is a critique of the article, which does note that, empirically, it is mostly moms juggling these particular glass balls. (And, as I learned the hard way, authors of pieces like this often don’t get to choose their own titles?) Moreover, the article doesn’t endorse individualized A.I. outsourcing as a solution to the problem of spiraling administrative tasks. So, let’s note that this is probably a structural problem as well as an individual household problem and that it should be a parent problem not a mom problem, and now let’s move on.
Evidently, many parents are turning to A.I. for help. A survey cited in the article found that “2 in 3 parents reported that A.I. reduced their mental load, saving them on average more than 58 minutes a week.” The parents interviewed talk about outsourcing life management to A.I. so they can “be more present” with their kids, and the article’s photographs show the interviewees enjoying the kinds of moments we all wish made up a larger share of parenting time: reading stories or playing games with smiling kids.
I’d like more of those moments, and more presence, myself.
But for several reasons, I won’t be outsourcing managerial work to A.I. agents anytime soon. I find the start-up costs daunting. I’m afraid of A.I. I’m angry about A.I. My partner is (more knowledgeably) afraid of and angry about A.I. We are both disposed toward being fairly comprehensive abstainers. We tend to think that the problems of spiraling mental load are social problems that we all should suffer through together. (But I’d be presenting myself as more virtuous than I am if I let you think this last one weighed decisively for me. I rely on plenty of individualized solutions to social problems rather than suffering in solidarity.)
For me, there’s another reason: I just don’t want robots juggling these balls for us, even if the robots can juggle at least as well as we can, and even if we could spare ourselves time and grief by my handing the juggling over.
These are balls I want us to juggle ourselves.
But…why? This is not like asking the robots to compose emails to friends, to write my papers, to script the conversations I have with my spouse, or to make important parenting decisions. Bracketing existential fear and rage, this is, as household labor-saving technology goes, more like a dishwasher or salad spinner. At best, it saves you time and spares you the mess of manually swinging wet lettuce above your head wrapped in a tea towel. It’s not displacing bedtime stories, sick-kid snuggles, or shooting hoops in the driveway. These parents aren’t outsourcing the core work of loving, caring for, and raising their kids. I think they’re probably giving robots a lot of access to information, and they’re opening themselves up to unforeseen error. But supposing the robot drops no more balls than I do, and bracketing questions of safety and existential threat, the technology seems continuous with other technologies that support parental managerial work—like the hanging kitchen calendar that my family relies on, imperfectly, to keep scheduling balls in the air.
But in one respect, these A.I. apps are not continuous with the hanging calendar: Unlike the calendar, the A.I. is not going to help me juggle; it’s going to juggle for me. I can’t draw that line with precision, but it’s a line I mysteriously find myself caring about. It turns out that these are balls I want to juggle—and drop—myself, even though the juggling isn’t the core work of loving, caring for, and raising the kids.
I have a good friend, a woman in her 70s, whose doctors have repeatedly urged her to start taking GLP-1s. She has several of the serious health conditions that GLP-1s have been found to help treat. But she won’t do it. I can imagine lots of good reasons to refuse GLP-1s, but I’m not persuaded by the reason she gives: “I just want to lose the weight myself.” She thinks it’s better to manage your health conditions through the sheer force of will than through medical intervention. I get it, I even admire it, but I think it’s mistaken. It’s better that the conditions be managed well with technological help than that they be managed less well through sheer force of will. Or anyway, so I’m presently inclined to think.
When I learn of myself that I want to juggle (and drop) the balls myself, I suppose I learn that I have the inverse conviction about family logistics: It’s better that the balls get juggled by me (and my partner) than that they get juggled better but not by me. This could be pure taste—that is, it could be better for me, but only because I prefer it. But I think there’s something my preference is tracking here. I wonder if at the end of the day, I think that managing logistics, in this historical moment, actually is core to the parental role. Maybe that’s why I want it to be me doing it (assisted by technology) rather than technology doing it (assisted by me). (That and the aforementioned fear, rage, and laziness about startup costs.)
I’m not saying I want the logistics for their own sake. I’d rather live in a world where parenting is less managerially taxing. But in a world where parenting is managerially taxing, I suppose I want that to be a part of my experience. I evidently want it to be a part of my experience even if it’s a drag, even if it demands more spousal negotiation, and even if there’s some shattered glass from the dropped balls that the technology could have kept in the air. Of course, I could be wrong to think that management is (contingently) a core part of parenting. But my preferences apparently do suggest that I think that, or something like it.
There’s a different possibility to consider, though: Maybe I’m dissuaded by the startup costs but bitter that those with a higher tolerance for startup costs can avail themselves of this great technology that will free them up for stories, sick-kid snuggles, and shooting hoops. So, in classic sour grapes fashion, I rationalize up a reason, better than my own laziness, to abstain.
{ 18 comments }
engels 10.29.26 at 3:18 pm
On a previous thread some people were asking how a malignant AI could get us all killed… I think this might present some novel causal pathways.
Aviva Mar 10.30.26 at 3:33 am
The library-book due-date example is painfully specific in the best way. Managerial load is invisible until something like that fails, and “I’d rather drop the balls myself” captures why handing the remembering to an app can feel worse than the overload. The Times piece on AI as a second brain sits awkwardly next to that instinct. My question is whether any of those apps show their reasoning before they nudge you, or whether they just surface another notification that still needs a human to decide if it matters.
Gina Schouten 10.30.26 at 12:36 pm
Aviva, I agree about the library book example. And I have been curious about the nudges too, less about the transparency of the reasoning than about the timing. I get plenty of nudges in the forms of emails and messages on what feel like a million different platforms. But if they happen to come through in the middle of breakfast chaos and I can’t put the library book in the backpack at that precise moment, it’s likely to fly out of my brain by the time I have a free hand anyway. Maybe the value add of the reminders is that they are all in one place?
David O'Brien 10.30.26 at 2:41 pm
“It’s better that the balls get juggled by me (and my partner) than that they get juggled better but not by me. This could be pure taste—that is, it could be better for me, but only because I prefer it.”
Gina, the bit above made me wonder if a Jerry-Cohen-style conservatism might be part of what’s backing your thought here (or, if not your thought, *one* way of backing your thought). Like, there’s a valuable way of doing things *that we now have*. And “as a valuable social creation, it merits preservation, and a radical enough transformation of it would induce both deformation of our identity and, with that, a loss of (some of) the distinctive value that [it] embodies”, and hence a “bias in favor of retaining what is of value, even in the face of replacing it with something of greater value” (Cohen).
I think that’s interestingly related to, but maybe a bit different from, the thought that juggling the balls oneself is core to, or essential to, the parenting role as such. (Because to take the Cohen-conservative view about this, one wouldn’t have to say that, if the AI stuff described in the article became very widespread, the resulting practice would no longer recognizably *be* parenting. One could just say it’s not *our* form of parenting.) And I think the Cohen-conservative view also comports with, what you later say, not being friendly to parenting being managerially taxing as such. (Because presumably there’s *other* ways of altering how managerially taxing parenting is that, nonetheless, wouldn’t be such a radical change to the valuable existing parenting practice.) On the other hand, I like the view, so maybe I just see it everywhere now!
Michel 10.30.26 at 4:57 pm
I also have a five year-old. And my partner and I care for the children alone, because we have no childcare.
As far as the specific example goes, I have to say… It’s not that hard to make a habit of packing the library books at the same time as you pack the lunch box. Sure, the different days thing is really annoying, but it’s not any harder for me to just print the schedule and pack the nooks the night before, or the morning of. It’s a matter of developing the habit.
D. S. Battistoli 10.30.26 at 5:34 pm
Thanks so much for sharing! (I was only able to read the first five paragraphs without creating a New York Times account, and I have this odd 20th-c. belief that my reading a single article does not privilege a publication to keep my identity on record).
I do think that the conceptualization of parenting as comprising “administration,” “management,” “labor,” and “tasks” as part of a sort of petit-bourgeois-ification of parenthood. Or, to get away from the marxian terminology, if we conceptualize parenting as managing, then why wouldn’t an effective parent “delegate” or “assign” “tasks” to an entity that can perform them with maximal efficiency, freeing up the manager themselves to do things best-suited for the manager’s “role” and “skill set”?
Now, in support of your point, Gina, I think part of parenting is socializing children to see what it is to be a person. When my eldest sees me or another older member of the household do something, soon enough, she wants to practice the same, with toys, with her younger sibling, or with us adults. If I shove essential activities over to an AI agent, then that is not that different from raising a child to be unable to function in a house without a butler or a maid (“oh, my parents never did that, the computer programs they paid for always did. How do people ever get by doing that, in addition to everything else?”).
Especially given the uncertainty around future price points for AI (even top paid accounts are subsidized, according to some calculations, by a factor of up to 5:1, and though costs may come down in the future, it’s not unlikely to wind up like periodicals on the internet: once, all of everything was free, and now much of what existed has gone bankrupt and what is left is paywalled for even minor usage), I feel I would be remiss in not socializing my children to see what a human “juggling the glass balls” looks like.
(And plus, my kindergarten teachers, on a different continent than where I live, communicated with my parents by putting notes in my backpack. My eldest’s kindergarten teachers do the same. Sometimes, notes got missed by my father, and sometimes I miss notes. These are not “glass balls,” and it is useful for kindergarteners to learn what to do when they feel “bummed” in any event).
But maybe I am being the 21st-c. equivalent of a luddite. People “outsource” their physical activity tracking and planning to apps; they set their phones to tell them when to wake, what the weather will be, and how to get around their hometown. Maybe the game is already played.
Maybe all the Times‘ readers think of themselves as little household managers already, and this kind of news is just a helpful hint to them.
Gina Schouten 10.30.26 at 6:23 pm
I like this idea, David! (And I see it everywhere too. I suspect that in this case I have you rather than Cohen to thank for that. :))
I recoiled a little when I read you writing that your thought is different from the thought that juggling is *essential* to parenting, and I had to go back to make sure I used the lazily ambiguous “core to” rather than “essential to.” I definitely want a less managerial parenting to still be parenting! I’m just struck by how robust it is in my experience that in conversations with other parents (including across social classes) we are all doing a lot of managerial work and wishing we were doing less.
I wonder if the thing I want to preserve Cohen-style about parenting is its laboriousness? And since in families without a primary at-home caregiver, management is now a major form of laboriousness (a lot of the other parts of parenting are pretty fun or nice when you’re not doing them all day every day), I actually prefer that labor for its own sake even though ideally I’d prefer for parental laboriousness to take a different form?
David O'Brien 10.30.26 at 6:49 pm
Oh, yes (on your first thing): I’d thought only that you might have wanted to say that ‘being managed by us’ was the core thing, not ‘being managed laboriously by us’! I also think you’re right that figuring out which ‘bit’, exactly your valuing attitude attaches to here is important and a bit subtle!
paul 10.30.26 at 9:19 pm
Some (by no means all) of this managerial load is pointless busy-work. Parents are busy enough already without having “books .. due on different days each week in accordance with a rotating printed schedule .. brought home from kindergarten”.
Who makes up such rules?
But, AI is pretty good at pointless busy-work, so I suppose why not use it in this way?
Matt 10.30.26 at 9:45 pm
I am pretty sympathetic to the main impulse. (Plus, it seems like this agent saves people… less than 10 minutes a day, not even taking into account set up time? Is that really a huge help?) But I also wonder if it’s not worth-while to let even pretty young kids juggle some of these balls. Can the kid keep track of due dates for books? Maybe it’s a pretty painless way to start learning things (including that pretty small setbacks are not worth getting really bummed out about?)
Jimmy 10.31.26 at 3:56 am
The structural framing is the strongest part of this – turning ‘moms need a second brain’ into ‘households need shared infrastructure’ names the product pitch for what it is: individualized patching for a coordination failure. Where an assistant like Ollie does genuinely help is the boring reliability layer – rotating schedules, due dates – precisely because that is work nobody should be holding mentally in the first place. The risk is that convenient tools lower the pressure to fix the structure: each patch makes the underlying system slightly more tolerable, so the structural conversation keeps getting deferred. The same pattern shows up in ops tooling generally – the band-aid becomes permanent the moment it works well enough.
D. S. Battistoli 10.31.26 at 1:39 pm
Apparently my first comment is still in an approval queue, but this quote from an article by Belinda Luscombe in Time magazine I just read this morning seems pertinent:
The article addresses direct usage of AI by children, but I believe it also addresses well to the use-case of parents trying to avoid “dropping” “glass balls” by integrating digital tools (both AI and others) into their effort to Taylorize their child-implicating “managerial” schemes.
As in my first comment, I still support Gina’s interrogation in her penultimate paragraph as to whether “management,” with “outsourcing,” “negotiation,” “startup costs,” (Susskind’s “transaction”), and the like, provides an effective conceptual model for what parents do with children. It seems to leave us with questions like, “what is the appropriate level of mechanization of the 18-year-long young-adult production line?” and “how much leeway should managers have to pilot or standardize new technologies when producing young adults?” that rely so heavily on metaphor as to make them difficult to answer.
engels 10.31.26 at 3:28 pm
Parents are busy enough already without having “books .. due on different days each week in accordance with a rotating printed schedule .. brought home from kindergarten”.
Who makes up such rules?
Perhaps it was an AI?
Harry 10.31.26 at 5:31 pm
I ended up with a smart phone not because I could watch cricket (a plus) or so that I could check my email (a minus) or the weather (neutral), but because all the mothers (and they were all mothers) on the soccer and parents (a few of whom were fathers) on the football (different kids) car-share lists had smart phones, and it was impossible to coordinate with them on my stupid phone. I ended up doing a lot of the driving myself for various reasons.
The moral?: I had to use smart technology to even be in the game of managing certain aspects of their lives. I can imagine you’ll be pushed ever more toward AI in a war of attrition.
ANother point though. Why was there all that driving to practices?
In fact, it was socially acceptable for parents not to be at the practices, which is what made ride sharing possible. It was necessary because i) even well before their teens there was an expectation that involvement in a sport requires very high levels of formal practice, with formal coaches and ii) almost nothing is walkable and nothing at all was bussable by an unaccompanied pre-teen. None of those things applied in my childhood.
But not attending the formal games was not socially acceptable (so no ride-sharing). I’ve watched so much dreadful soccer, played on pitches nobody has tended to, watched by hundreds of parents. I guess I’ve watched lots of bad football too, but I can’t tell because the whole thing is incomprehensible to me. Oh, and lots of cross country (a sport where the whole experience of watching it is 30 seconds of them disappearing from view, and somewhat later one minute of seeing them get to the finish line and peeing themselves, or vomiting or fainting, or all three, in public).
Contrast with my own childhood (different time and place): I’ve calculated that I played between 150 and 200 cricket matches between ages 12 and 16. My mum never once came to see me. My dad came to see me three times (at least 30 of the matches must have been within 500 yards of my home). They both loved me, at least somewhat, and both loved cricket, much more than somewhat. If they were unusual it was not in their having interesting things to do that weren’t watching kids play cricket [I nearly added “badly”, but by the time we were 15 we were bloody good actually, and I now remember that two of the matches dad did come to included soon-to-be first class players, one of whom became an England Test bowler], but the extent to which they both liked the sport I participated in. If any parent had regularly watched us, we’d have thought they were weirdos. Oh, and we got ourselves to practices (by bike mainly). And before I was 12 — no organised activities, I just read books, watched telly, played, sometimes with friends. I did ask to join the Cubs/Scouts but my parents regarded that as a paramilitary organization so didn’t allow me to go, which was, I now think, fair enough. My friends might go to judo, or cubs, or choir, once a week. But nothing like the intense schedule designed for upper middle class children here. (Dad once talked about my eldest daughter’s “Annette Lareau life”).
The management load imposed by these expectations, in an urban and suburban geography designed so that it is essentially impossible for children to get around independently, is huge. And it’s made worse by what, from the outside (and I have always felt like an outsider) feels like a pathological level of social pressure to spend one’s time watching one’s children do things like sports. [This of course maintains certain class cleavages, and probably race cleavages, but it also overwhelms and exhausts parents who keep up]. I wish I’d dropped more balls, to be honest.
John Q 11.01.26 at 10:09 am
It’s better to lose weight yourself, if you can, than to rely on a pill, especially if you end up taking more than one kind. But while I managed with weight, largely on exercise, I couldn’t control my cholesterol levels that way, and I wasn’t willing to make the necessary changes in diet. So, I’ve been on daily statins for the last 20 years or so.
J, not that one 11.01.26 at 6:38 pm
*Parents are busy enough already without having “books .. due on different days each week in accordance with a rotating printed schedule .. brought home from kindergarten”.
Who makes up such rules?*
I imagine someone found a rotating 6 day schedule was easier given various administrative needs, and that having a computer in the school office made it possible for the staff where previously it would have been an administrative nightmare.
dilbert dogbert 11.02.26 at 6:55 pm
I asked a question: Is Ai misogynist? I did that because it struck me that 90% of the training corpus is male. The ans was: Yes
ETB 11.03.26 at 8:45 am
Setting aside the broader issues for a moment – the dangers of AI; the systemic failure to recognise the importance of labour (reproductive labour in particular); what seems to be one of capitalism’s more reliable forms of innovation (creating the problem, for example escalating curation, then
sellingrenting the solution, such as tools to help manage these demands) – is it not fundamentally odd to place this much pressure, and this much additional work, on children and parents?Perhaps, one day, we might consider organising society for the benefit and convenience of the people within it, rather than the other way around…?
Comments on this entry are closed.