Two months ago, I saw No Other Land in a large movie theatre in Brussels. No Other Land is a documentary made by a team of two Palestinians and two Israeli.
We follow their reporting on the years-long destruction of Masafer Yatta, a village on the Palestinian Westbank, by Israeli forces. The Israeli State, backed up by its army, orders the villagers to leave the land because the land will be used by the army for training; but the villagers have lived there for generations and are the owners of the land. As one woman says, “there is no other land” they could go to.
The documentary was at the same time horrible and beautiful.
Horrible – because the documentary hits us in the face how step by step, gradually but consistently, the Palestinians are driven off their land. Some villagers move to nearby caves. The villagers fight courageously to keep their houses and schools, only to see the bulldozers arriving to destroy the buildings, every time they rebuild them. A peaceful protestor is shot and barely survives, spending the remainder of his life in pain and largely paralyzed in a cave. All this makes it clear that these people just have no rights. They are completely at the mercy of Israeli soldiers, and later on at the mercy of some armed Israeli settlers who have moved into nice new houses nearby. The injustice just splashes off the canvas.
But it was also beautiful – artistically, because of the way the real-life activist footing is combined with fine shots of the deeply human dialogues between the two protagonists – the Palestinian activist and villager Basel and the Israeli journalist Yuval. And beautiful also in a human sense. We are invited to witness how Basel and Yuval develop a friendship against the odds – even though it is clear that the very unequal rights they are enjoying, and hence their vastly unequal civic status, also casts a shadow over their friendship. After all, Yuval can at any point leave the territory, and could also just decide to leave this conflict altogether and do something else with his life – freedoms Basel does not have.
When the movie was finished, one could hear a needle drop in the theater room. Lives are ruined; villages are destroyed; victims of structural injustice have no way to defend them; and the world hardly gives a damn. Does the world sufficiently know, one might ask?
So far, No Other Land won multiple prizes, and is nominated for an Oscar next week. Yet I learnt from the film review in the New York Times that the film could not find a distributor in the USA. Why, oh why? Implicitly the NYT says: Not enough scope for profits; there isn’t enough demand for this type of documentary. This is truly saddening. Because with the US being the most important ally of Israel, the American citizens (and citizens of other countries that are staunch defenders of Israel) have the right to know what is going on in Israel – and not just the horrendous attack by Hamas that ended in the dystopian destruction of Gaza – but also what has been happening much more quietly for many years now in other places in Palestinian Territories. And of course such citizens can read reports by civil society organizations, or journalistic accounts. But the power of this documentary is that it is not a fictious story – it is the raw reality – but at the same time it has a strong narrative and it is much more humane than cold statistics. It would be hard to not develop more sympathy for the Palestinian cause if one sees this move. Is this perhaps part of the explanation for why it hasn’t found a distributor?
Just make sure you see No Other Land when it is in a movie theatre nearby you.
{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }
JCO 03.01.25 at 1:43 am
Thanks for this review!
Bob 03.01.25 at 3:16 am
Thanks for this Ingrid. You’ll be pleased to know that this film is showing in Toronto, to no opposition or controversy that I am aware of. I haven’t seen it yet, but was planning to. It was also reviewed, favourably, in the Globe and Mail, a national newspaper in Canada. What is important in this story is that it isn’t tainted by the usual cross-recriminations: you attacked us, but that was because you did X, but that was because . . . and so on. This is a case where the Israelis are simply and unambiguously in the wrong.
Gareth Richard Samuel Wilson 03.01.25 at 7:45 am
“After all, Yuval can at any point leave the territory, and could also just decide to leave this conflict altogether and do something else with his life – freedoms Basel does not have.”
Here’s a video clip of Basel in Berlin, so he obviously can leave the territory when he wants: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nZBbOBPLSvA
Ingrid Robeyns 03.01.25 at 8:29 am
Gareth @3 – thanks, I should clarify. In the documentary there are a couple of scenes where Yuval decides to go home, and just drives off. He can, because the carplate of his car has a coding that shows he lives in Israel, and there is no difficulty for Isrealis to cross the line between Israel and the Palestinian Territories on the Westbank. Basel’s car-plate shows he is a citizen from the Palestinian Territories, and he can’t just decide to go with Yuval to Israel whenever he pleased.
But you are pointing to something interesting, and that is how the question of how the life that Basel might have changed after (and because of) the movie. It has indeed been shown (and won prizes) at several international Film Festivals where they travel to. I’d be interesting to read a recent interview with Basel to see how he experiences this and reflects on this, but I haven’t read one (admittedly, I also haven’t searched for one!).
Laban 03.01.25 at 11:21 am
Does the world sufficiently know, one might ask?
It definitely helps if you have a megaphone handy. Even in the Guardian, comments are frequently open where Putin and Trump may be castigated, but resolutely closed if the op-ed deals with Gaza or the West Bank. And comments even elsewhere mentioning the g-word in a Gaza context are instantly moderated.
At least they still report.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/mar/01/footage-shows-last-moments-boy-12-killed-in-west-bank
Ingrid Robeyns 03.01.25 at 12:56 pm
Here are CT we know there are a couple of topics that always attracts trolls and worse – and sadly Israel-Palestine is one of them. So, just to remind everyone that I will delete anything that to me sounds like trolling or worse, sweeping claims without any arguments, or incomprehensible comments/rants. And thank you to our regular readers and commenters who are carrying this blog forward with productive conversations.
Cristina 03.02.25 at 3:06 am
Happy to share itt opens on Miami Beachthis Friday & I am absolutely going. Such an important film!!!
Ingrid Robeyns 03.02.25 at 4:43 pm
On Bluesky Robert Hunter shared the information that in the UK No Other Land can now be streamed on Channel 4.
Matt 03.02.25 at 8:53 pm
In Australia you can watch it on Amazon prime video, either as a rental or w/ a free trial of their docmentary channel. (Prime sometimes has different offerings in different countries so I don’t know if it’s available like this outside of Australia.)