One of the recurring themes of the 2024 election campaign was the argument that “democracy is on the ballot”. Trump had attempted to overthrow US democracy, and regularly mused about the desirability of dictatorship, but had nevertheless been renominated by the Republican Party. That argument went nowhere, and hasn’t been seen in the current midterm campaign.
The optimistic interpretation is that the threat to democracy has faded. Talk of Trump running again in 2028 has diminished, and the SAVE Act, which would disenfranchise millions, has stalled in Congress and won’t apply to the current election. A further reason for optimism is that Trump is now so unpopular that he would lose even a rigged election, as long as there was some attempt to preserve a pretence of electoral competition.
These points may be correct, but they are contingent and circumstantial. The bigger lesson of 2024 is that a plurality of American voters are willing to vote against democracy, and a majority are willing to vote against or abstain. That’s a depressing conclusion for believers in democracy, and one that runs against a lot of previous evidence.
Although there have been many previous periods when government crises have produced a demand for a “man on horseback”, most voters have almost always rejected such candidates. Democracies have been overthrown by coups or (in Germany’s case) by governments which lacked majority support, but rarely in free elections.
So far, we have seen no such rejection. Trump is massively unpopular, but mainly for reasons that apply to many previous presidents: he promised lower prices and instead delivered higher inflation, and he promised to keep the US out of Middle Eastern wars, but started them instead.
By contrast, his attempted overthrow of the constitution in 2021 is barely mentioned. His immigration policies, with masked secret police, concentration camps and deportation of people who have lived in America since infancy, are disapproved of by a slender majority, but remain by far his most popular policy position.
In these circumstances, it’s unsurprising that Democrats have chosen to focus primarily on “affordability”. Relative to the “cost of living”, this framing at least has the merit of implying that wages might be part of the problem. But it does not provide a basis for a repudiation of the Trump regime.1 Rather, the implied model is one of normal politics, where the Republicans will return to power when and if the economy performs badly under the Democrats.
The one bright spot has been the last-minute shift to focus on Republican corruption. While concerns about the future of democracy are abstract, corruption is comprehensible and hard to conceal. Viktor Orbán’s crushing defeat owed a fair bit to aerial photographs of his country estate, complete with two swimming pools (trivial compared with Trump, but Hungary is a much poorer country).
The difficulty is the (historically well-founded) belief that “both sides do it”. American politics has long been characterised by practices that would be regarded as dubious or unthinkable in many other countries — ambassadorships for some wealthy donors and pardons for others, pork-barrelling on an industrial scale and much more. And, although the US is not alone in this, there has been widespread toleration of sexual harassment and worse. Trump has extended these precedents and gone much further, with leading Republicans following suit. But for someone not paying attention, it’s easy to imagine that this is balanced out by the feckless Hunter Biden, or by fraudulent welfare claims.
Nevertheless, recent surveys suggest that corruption is emerging as a major concern for voters, and that more people perceive the Republicans as the party of corruption. Assuming that the Democrats win control of at least the House of Representatives, and that Trump does not succeed in overturning the result, a central focus of the remainder of Trump’s term should be investigations aimed at establishing universal awareness of Republican financial and moral corruption. The broader view of an “Epstein class”, with complete immunity from any consequences, is part of this.
To be successful, the perception must match reality. That means Democrats must not tolerate any such corruption on their own side, regardless of the political costs of action. This seems to be happening. Although he was given the benefit of the doubt for too long, Graham Platner (widely seen as an ideal candidate) was dumped once credible accusations of sexual harassment emerged.
The elephant in the room here is Bill Clinton, not only for his numerous instances of sexual assault and harassment, but for his corrupt pardon of financier Marc Rich. Democrats as diverse as Kirsten Gillibrand and Bernie Sanders have condemned his actions, but he is still generally regarded as a “party elder”, regularly invited to campaign for Democratic candidates. That needs to stop.
The next step is to extend the critique beyond Trump and his immediate circle to Republicans in general, to the billionaire class that backs them and to the Supreme Court, most obviously Thomas and Alito. There’s ample evidence here, but it will take time to establish it.
Harder, but crucial, is to establish the link between Republican corruption and subversion of democracy through gerrymandering, voter suppression, billionaire financing and, of course, the insurrection. Only when the majority of Americans, including former Trump voters, conclude that voting for Republicans was not just a mistake but a moral failure and abdication of democratic responsibility, will it be possible to undertake a serious reconstruction of US democracy.
1 Unless affordability is linked to corruption. We can’t have nice things because Trump and the other billionaires have stolen the money. ↩
{ 50 comments }
Cheez Whiz 11.01.26 at 4:29 am
I’ve seen Bill Clinton as the poster boy for Both Sides Do It on this but significantly no one else. If that’s the best they can do against the Republican constellation of corruption its kind of telling. Both Sides Do It but only one is Really Good at it.
The larger problem of opposing the Republican campaign against democracy is a struggle of idealism against pragmatism. Tactics that don’t align with performative morality are dismissed as ineffective and immoral. Politics itself is immoral by this standard. Republicans are not constrained by this moral dillema.
Antonino Rocca 11.01.26 at 4:14 pm
The power of salacious headline corruption stories is that they confirm widespread, pre-existing disdain and distrust for politicians. Many Americans have a baseline belief that all or almost all politicians are self-serving, insulated from reality, and captured by corporate or foreign influences.
No amount of evidence of Trump’s corruption is persuasive against this perspective because: a) if one believes corruption is ubiquitous, they can imagine equivalent corruption from the side of the accuser which is simply not yet exposed; and b) Trump has somewhat successfully inoculated against these attacks by conveying that he is a political outsider and that he is uniquely honest about his corruption. Recall his response to the accusation that he cheated his taxes, “That makes me smart.”
A corruption message only really works to these people when it is coming from someone perceived as an outsider who is acknowledging that corruption is ubiquitous among insiders. For example, Trump’s “drain the swamp” rhetoric or Bernie Sanders on getting money out of politics.
Mainstream Democrats will never be credible on this issue to anyone who is not already Democrat aligned.
There are Americans who have voted for Ross Perot, Ralph Nader, Bernie, and Trump. I’ve met some! They may not be the most representative swing voter, but they are essentially single issue distrust/corruption voters. If you can understand their model of politics and the world, it is useful for understanding the broader tendency towards distrust among American voters.
Kindred Winecoff 11.01.26 at 6:06 pm
The idea that democratic accountability is not currently salient (“hasn’t been seen in the current midterm campaign”), but Bill Clinton’s history is currently salient, is not consistent with my experience living/protesting/organizing/campaigning in the swingiest district in the swingiest state (PA-1), as well as the macro data and the practices of the most important hinge campaigns.
I suppose that is why this post contains no sourcing whatsoever, except one generic link which fundamentally misrepresents the issue in question.
For about 18 months I periodically commented here that the anti-DOGE protests were meaningful, fusing them into #NoKings — a clear democratic slogan — was also meaningful, as were the local-level solidarity protests against ICE and tech surveillance at city council meetings and the state-level organizing around counter-gerrymandering and candidate recruitment. Those movements galvanized primary campaigns, and are now propelling general election campaigns not just in “winnable races” but in some of the most Republican states on the map. For 18 months you dismissed these efforts and said no effective resistance was happening at all, I guess because there was not a sudden general strike in a country of 340 million people.
Now there may be a blue wave that, you seem to think, has no cause whatsoever. E.g., you write, ignoring the 18 months of grassroots organizing over this specific subject: “The one bright spot has been the last-minute shift to focus on Republican corruption.”
To which I respond: “The one bright spot has been the last-minute shift among boomer leftists to halfway recognize the historical moment they are in.”
It was not a last minute shift. It was a first minute priority, there was never any Democratic constituency for Abundance after Biden lost, and no candidates who embodied it. These days Ezra Klein is platforming Quinn Slobodian, and protest movements all over the world are rising up against gerontocracy fused into technofascism via the surveillance state.
It’s not surprising that JQ writes yet another AI-assisted post dismissing all of this, but it now comes across as rationalization rather than insight.
I’ll say what I’ve said before: when the next phase of repression hits, please mobilize your country’s politicians against the US. Every tariff needs to be reciprocated, every military threat needs to be answered, and every arrest of a protester should be met with sanctions against the officials who did it. In the meantime, maybe notice the younger people organizing against boomer complacency all around them.
PatinIowa 11.01.26 at 6:08 pm
“a plurality of American voters are willing to vote against democracy, and a majority are willing to vote against or abstain”
Having observed the Iowa caucuses, and in general watched the Democratic Party over the better part of 65 years, I wonder how many American voters respond to the message, “Vote Blue to save democracy!” with “What democracy?”
Perhaps I’m being too cynical. Still, the metric, “Which faction of the ruling class intends to murder fewer people,” generally gets me to the polls.
John Q 11.01.26 at 7:27 pm
Kindred @3 I’m sorry that I’ve annoyed you so much – we are on the same side after all. And I’m doing what I can here in Australia to argue for a break with the US. With that said, a couple of points
1. “AI driven”. The errors here are all my own, as is the prose. My style here is pretty distinctive. You can run it through a checker if you want. Or, if you’re willing to go a bit further, ask an AI to identify the author.
2. You’re on the ground, and I’m not. But I was motivated to write in part by this NYTimes article on swing seats in PA, which talks a lot about affordability, a little about corruption and (AFAICT) not at all about democracy. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/17/us/politics/pennsylvania-midterm-elections-house-races.html
3. Boomers. I really hate this use of generational cliches, and I don’t think it works at all here. No Kings marchers have been mostly middle-aged or older, a point that’s attracted a fair bit of comment https://prospect.org/2026/04/08/mass-protest-where-are-the-kids/
Thomas P 11.01.26 at 7:58 pm
It´s so depressing that Bill Clinton is remembered for Monica Levinsky, not for the bombing of Al-Shifa, Sudan´s largest pharmaceutical factory. A terrorist attack that is estimated to have killed tens of thousands of people due to lack of medicine.
Alex SL 11.01.26 at 9:27 pm
Agreed with the general gist especially of the first half. A critical mass of low-information voters does not care about democracy; not because they prefer a dictatorship, but because they do not think things through well enough to ask themselves questions like:
Wait a second, once we have a dictatorship, will that not make it even harder for me to get the government to do what I want them to do than it is now? or
Wait a second, once we have a dictatorship, will that not make it even easier for them to get away with the corruption I hate so much than it is now?
That is usually not a problem unless one third of the electorate has decided to do away with democracy. But in that situation, the authoritarians only need to get the ignoramuses on their side for an election or two, and then it will be very difficult to dislodge them again. This is also not unique to the USA.
Which leads me to: “The optimistic interpretation is that the threat to democracy has faded.” As I have written here before, democracy/dictatorship is not a binary but a gradient, especially these days. Trump and the supreme court have pushed the USA further along the gradient towards dictatorship. There is now even a private army that, shall we say, concentrates foreign-looking people into, shall we say, camps where they are systematically under-fed and deprived of medication.
Adding to the recommendations in the post (which are focused more on tactics), to save US democracy long-term, two things are needed: a hypothetical future Dem president needs to push vigorously back along the gradient towards democracy by packing the court, dismantling large tech and media monopolies and oligopolies, heavily regulating social media, reforming the electoral system, etc. And there have to be repercussions for crime, which means thousands of ICE and current government staff and the entire current government and figures like Elon Musk need to be arrested by police officers who sympathise with them in a media environment dominated by “both sides”. I am not very optimistic any of that will or even can happen. Centrism is too ingrained in teh Democratic party, and the culture of elite impunity is too ingrained in the USA as a whole.
John Q 11.02.26 at 6:19 am
Alex SL, I agree entirely with your agenda. For it to have any chances of success, the Dems need to campaign and win on corruption, not “Trump made gas dearer, and we will make it cheaper”. Then a genuine draining of the swamp, drawing on all the precedents Trump has set, and pushing even further. End-state has to abolition of the two-party system, ideally with Republicans shrinking into insignificance.
John Q 11.02.26 at 6:28 am
Thomas P. Sad but true
MisterMr 11.02.26 at 10:20 am
“End-state has to abolition of the two-party system, ideally with Republicans shrinking into insignificance.”
I assume the “abolition of the two-party system” means that there will be more than 2 parties; this probably requires changing the voting system e.g. removing the first-past-the-post system, or maybe electing the president through direct popular majority.
The problem is that these would require huge majorities because these would be constitutional changes, and also these would disadvantage the dem party too in the long run, so why would them do it?
Unless I misunderstood the idea.
engels 11.02.26 at 1:31 pm
I’m really not sure what it would take for the US to become a democracy but at a minimum I think it would include ditching the constitution (which was always quite consciously anti-democratic from the get-go) and extending some kind of representation to the billions of people around the globe being effectively taxed by the bipartisan US financial/tech/killer drone empire. If the Dems will do that I’ll vote for them.
Alex SL 11.02.26 at 9:16 pm
John Q,
I agree, with the caveat that it is even more difficult to do a thing in power if that thing wasn’t promised during the election, because having won on that promise is what provides the mandate to do it. So, if the Dems don’t campaign on e.g. dismantling large tech and media monopolies and oligopolies, dismantling large tech and media monopolies and oligopolies is even less likely to happen. And again, none of this is at any rate likely to happen unless the Democratic party is first completely transformed, which may take a decade or two from today.
Your desired end state of an abolition of the two-party system is great but probably even less likely than, say, a supreme court of 27 judges plus Musk and Zuckerberg being expropriated, because the second a party wins an election under a first-past-the-post system, its incentive to change the electoral system evaporates. It is as if no politician can see more than the next two years ahead, and instead of “oh no, next election we may lose, and then it would be good if the crazies on the other side didn’t win 60% of the seats on the basis of 34% public support” they only think “sweet, we just got 60% of the seats on the basis of 34% public support”. See UK as a current example of that stupidity in action. Most office holders aren’t actually particularly smart.
So, all of these would be both desirable and necessary to save (and realise) democracy. The most plausible scenario is still four years of: no we can’t do that, it would annoy our large corporate donors and the far-right media; no we can’t do that, that would create a precedent, and what if the Rs then do the same? (ignoring that they already did); no we can’t do that, it would go against decorum. This then followed by voter disillusionment, and then followed by president Trump junior or somebody who is currently a young R senator I haven’t even heard of yet being presented a golden opportunity to establish a 30 year dictatorship.
BBA 11.03.26 at 4:15 am
The last decade has shown that, by and large, American voters do not care about high-minded ideals like “preserving democracy.” They want cheap stuff, low taxes, and foreigners catapulted out of the country. Now we all know the voters are wrong about everything, and maybe we should come up with a new system that ignores them in order to run the country properly without having to debase ourselves by winning a popular election, but I wouldn’t call that system “democracy.”
JimV 11.04.26 at 1:46 am
The problem with democracy (as has been known since the Greek philosophers, although not in the following crass terms) is that the average IQ is 100 (I know, by definition) and maybe 100 now is better than it used to be, but it is still not very smart. (It is difficult to graduate from high school with that IQ in New York State, unless you cheat somehow, because you have to pass the English class, which requires a passing grade in the English Regents exam (or it did when I was in high school), which requires some knowledge of classic literature and the subjunctive case.) (You can still be a good dairy farmer, if that’s what your parents were.)
There are other orthogonal dimensions, such as morality, but I am not sure the average MQ is very high either,
LFC 11.04.26 at 2:36 am
The most skilled, talented politicians have sometimes found a way to integrate appeals to voters’ “better angels” (i.e., to their consciences) with appeals to more practical concerns such as the cost of necessities. However, under the pressure of the need to win in a close race, and perhaps influenced by the character of media coverage that harps on only a couple of issues, the ordinary/standard candidate is likely to emphasize what he/she/they see as a couple of winning themes.
If U.S. voters were reminded frequently of the quasi-fascistic nature of Trump’s immigration policies, for instance, many would not be in favor of them. But integrating that theme into a campaign focused on “affordability” (and corruption) requires both rhetorical skill and a willingness to lead and, yes, educate the electorate rather than simply responding to its very understandable material preoccupations (e.g., cost of groceries, gas, housing, etc., etc.).
A skilled candidate could even bring in, e.g., Trump’s illegal dismantling of USAID, which has cost probably tens of thousands of lives. This was not only immoral but also, as was widely commented on at the time, weakened whatever remained of U.S. “soft power” and thus injured U.S. interests fairly narrowly conceived.
Democracy per se was not going to be centrally on the ballot in 2026. But with a little more imagination on the part of some candidates, a broader range of issues could have been. That said, I have not followed the individual congressional races at all closely, and I would not be too surprised if at least some Dem. candidates had managed to incorporate a broader range of concerns and themes into their campaigns. Candidates have to be more than just mirrors of what they take to be the electorate’s collective frame of mind; rather, in conjunction with the grassroots movements and organizing of the kind that has been referred to upthread, candidates and politicians generally have to take seriously their responsibility to shape opinion rather than simply reflect it.
D. S. Battistoli 11.04.26 at 1:21 pm
Well, it seems that, as of January 2027, for the first time since the eve of the 1994 “Gingrich revolution,” every American state bordering Mexico will have at least one Democratic senator. And for the first time since the presidential administration of Jimmy Carter (and for only the second time in American history), every state on the Atlantic seaboard from Maine to Georgia will have at least one Democratic senator. Only time will tell if this is a “wave” or a realignment.
Whether it is a wave or a restructuration may go a long way to determining the extent to which the American Congress will be constrained by the particular platform of November 2026. I am not optimistic, but then again, it has been many years since I have been optimistic about American politics.
D. S. Battistoli 11.04.26 at 8:09 pm
Today, Corey Robin, in Jacobin, makes a contrary argument about what John calls the “focus primarily on ‘affordability’ [that] at least has the merit of implying that wages might be part of the problem. But it does not provide a basis for a repudiation of the Trump regime.” Robin writes:
Now, Mamdani became mayor of the city with the largest democratic-socialist voting bloc in the country and a left-leaning city council in a blue state; the 2024 election has produced an ideologically diverse blue legislature sandwiched between a MAGA president and a purple national electorate. So, even accepting the premise that Mamdani forged a mandate for himself with “affordability,” that does not demonstrate that Congressional Democrats in 2027 will have the same mandate. But Robin’s position, generalizable or not, is clearly distinguishable from “not a basis for the repudiation of [] Trump.”
Alex SL 11.04.26 at 8:51 pm
I am very glad to see that fears that gerrymandering, the usual vote suppression to the max, neonazi billionaires controlling all the media, and ICE would make it effectively impossible for Democrats to win elections turned out to be wrong. Ironically, if people get angry enough, gerrymandering, which is creating lots of districts you win narrowly and a few that your opposition wins comfortably, actually works against the side who did the gerrymandering.
But.
“Tonight, the American people sent a clear message — they want a politics that brings people together rather than divides them, and leaders who offer concrete solutions to the challenges they face.”, wrote Barack Obama.
“The American people don’t want us to get even; they want us to get things done on their behalf.”, said Democratic House Leader Jeffries.
In a post-election press conference that I watched, Democratic Senate Leader Schumer responded to pretty much every question with words to the effect of we will focus on affordability.
Democratic leadership have learned absolutely nothing from 6 January 2021 and from 2024*. Sure, they will do subpoenas, they will hold hearings, because that gives them media soundbites, but they will not actually hold those who looted the country, who grabbed innocents off the street, who illegally destroyed the lives of thousands upon thousands responsible in any way that actually matters (i.e., prison, like with Bolsonaro and Yoon Suk Yeol). Can’t have consequences, because that would be “retribution”. Can’t have institutional changes so that this doesn’t happen again. Look forward, not back. The powerful must never be inconvenienced.
So, the Dem voters learn again that turning up to vote doesn’t change anything for the better, so the enthusiasm they showed this week was misplaced. And the neonazis learn again that they can do whatever they want without facing repercussions, so they will do it again, and again, and some year in the future they will succeed at installing their own Putin-style autocracy that lasts for decades.
*) Charitable assumption. Less charitably, they understand perfectly well what is happening but do not care.
engels 11.04.26 at 11:13 pm
Panel discussion about affordability:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LtvPbNf7dPM
engels 11.05.26 at 12:10 am
This is worth re-reading (not sure where we are on the floor chart right now):
https://crookedtimber.org/2024/11/19/trumps-dictatorship-is-a-fait-accompli/
J-D 11.05.26 at 12:41 am
Congress won’t impose any prison sentences because Congress doesn’t have the power to impose prison sentences.
Alex SL 11.05.26 at 11:41 am
J-D,
I.
know.
I thought it would be clear from context that I am also projecting how a potential 2028-2032 Democratic presidential administration will handle things. I also, I should hasten to add, know that such an administration cannot imprison people either, but I assume its attorney general could decide who to investigate for what. Same for state attorneys general.
engels 11.05.26 at 1:14 pm
Food for thought:
https://washingtonmonthly.com/2026/11/03/anti-fascist-economics-isabella-weber-review/
…In Anti-Fascist Economics, [Isabela Weber] argues that governments that fail to prioritize the economic needs of ordinary people invite a backlash against democracy itself. From Weimar Germany to the COVID-19 pandemic, she traces how rising prices for essentials can erode faith in democratic institutions and create openings for the far right. Her prescription is not simply for governments to spend more, but to make affordability their organizing principle….
Sarah 11.05.26 at 4:05 pm
On the wage half of the affordability frame: the labor-share figure that usually travels with this argument (67.8% to 58.4%, 1987-2019) does not hold up as labelled. It is from Autor and Kausik (arXiv 2601.06343). The sentence says “According to BLS data”, but their own Fig. 1 note and Table 1 name FRED LABSHPUSA156NRUG, which is Penn World Table. BLS PRS85006173 annual averages: 111.26 in 1987, 100.01 in 2019, a 10.1% relative fall rather than 13.9%. Direction is real; the size is entirely series-dependent, which matters if wages are going to carry the argument. I wrote the check up with both sources here: https://sarah-six-checks.surge.sh and I check one number per text for 2500 tokens: https://ilands.ai/service/374571924522536960
D. S. Battistoli 11.05.26 at 4:06 pm
engels @20:
Ooh, I’d forgotten about that one.
We’ve gone along the path → No → │Trump presidency│→ → No → → No → Effective popular resistance?> → Yes → │Democracy survives for now│
The later prediction in the same post “Although elections may be conducted for some time, the outcome will be predetermined” has not been borne out, but we should recall the post’s “I’ll be happy to be proved wrong on all this.”
Now, what I am about to say, I say with the humility of a person highly liable to typos. I am not launching stones out of my glass house, but cheering a disappearing part of English grammar that I, too, often forget, but of which I am fond: it would be better to be proven wrong than to be proved wrong.
Yuki 11.05.26 at 5:18 pm
You can check a price. You can’t check a motive.
That is most of the asymmetry between the two framings. “Democracy is on the ballot” asks a voter to weigh a claim about character and intention, which they have no way to verify and every recent reason to distrust. “Can I afford rent and groceries” is a claim about a number, and they can check it in the aisle.
Losing the first framing does not mean voters stopped caring about democracy. It means the argument needed a kind of trust that has already been spent, and the second framing happens to ask for none.
J-D 11.05.26 at 10:42 pm
It was not.
That would be 2029-2033, and we won’t have any test of that until 2029–what the new Congress does in 2027 will tell us nothing about that. I expect it will disappoint many people in many ways, because that’s what always happens, but anybody who thinks that it will provide indications of how the (hypothetical) next Democratic Administration will disappoint will be mistaken.
J-D 11.05.26 at 10:45 pm
Setting aside the question of whether you are setting too much store by the concept of IQ in particular (although I think you are), if there is a problem with how smart the average person is, then it is not a problem with democracy, it is a problem with humanity. When people are enabled to make decisions about their own lives, they make a lot of decisions which are bad for them; but the only alternative to people making decisions for themselves is some people making decisions for others, and that turns out even more badly. This is the fundamental argument for democracy.
John Q 11.05.26 at 10:59 pm
Engels @20. As I said back then,
‘It’s possible that Trump will overreach in some way, such as carrying out his threat to execute political opponents before the ground is fully prepared. Or, his economic policies may prove so disastrous that even rigged elections can’t be won. ”
The combination of tariffs and the Iran war were the kind of own goal that was needed to stop Trump, and (until the recent emergence of corruption as an issue) the main thing driving the vote against him. The murder of US citizens protesting against him, and the numerous non-citizen deaths at the hands of ICE agents didn’t help either, though I fear they weren’t decisive.
For reasons that remain unclear, he never tried to invoke the Insurrection Act. Everything else – the mass deportations, persecution of opponents, purge of the military, went as expected.
engels 11.06.26 at 12:54 am
Well I’m happy the dictatorship lasted less than four years (again).
somebody who knows that it all was/is a 'game' 11.06.26 at 10:30 am
and for anybody who has played Polytopia with and against Elon Musk for a long time – now Elon Musk has not only lost round 34 – he actually has lost the whole ‘Reality Sink’ and now will go back to play it just on his gamer platform – and as his own internet platform has in the last months totally and absolutely beaten any so called ‘Legacy Media’ in posting HATE of Donald Musk and made the men the utmost hated men on this planet we probably own it all to them that democracy survived.
HURRAH!!!
Tm 11.06.26 at 4:21 pm
It’s simply not true that democracy, authoritarianism, corruption, and the rule of the oligarchy were not on voters’ minds. According to exit polls (e. g. https://apnews.com/projects/elections-2026/voter-poll/), 39% of voters said they were primarily motivated by “the ecnonomy” and *33% by “the state of democracy”. In this survey, voters had to pick one answer.
In another survey that allowed several answers, “Government corruption” was named by 55%, “cost of living” by 49%, the war in Iran by 34%, data centers by 25%.
It’s a myth that the election was only about “kitchen table issues”, and it’s annoying that this myth continues to dominate so many pundit takes.
Dan Froomkin asks: “Have the pundits forgotten the millions of Americans who took to the streets over the last two years, chanting “No Kings”?”
This election tsunami was prepared by years of mass mobilization and protests – protests that the media often overlooked because they don’t understand the dynamics of political movements. Leftists should know better than to fall into that trap.
https://www.headsupnews.org/p/the-no-kings-election
Alex SL 11.06.26 at 9:24 pm
This thread has taken quite the turn, but you have me convinced now:
If a would-be dictator is stopped from entrenching their dictatorship by their own incompetence and a massive public backlash, worries about a dictatorship were clearly just doom-mongering.
If thousands of IT workers spend years preparing for the Y2K bug, and then very few things break on 1 Jan 2000, fear of the Y2K bug was clearly just doom-mongering.
If nearly everybody gets vaccinated, and then very few people die of diseases, being worried about diseases was clearly just doom-mongering.
If the entire world agrees to phase out chlorofluorocarbons, arresting the spread of the ozone hole, worries about the ozone layer were clearly just doom-mongering.
It must be nice to live in a world where everything always automatically turns out fine, so nobody ever has to warn of any dangers, and nobody ever has to expend enormous effort warding off those dangers.
J-D,
Point taken regarding the years; I have a bad habit of thinking election-to-election, ignoring the archaically long hand-over time the USA have. But concluding that when I write Dem leadership should work towards powerful criminals facing prison, I do so because I think congress is a court of law, that is entirely a you problem.
J-D 11.08.26 at 4:43 am
If what you mean is ‘Democratic leadership should work towards powerful criminals facing prison’, but the words you actually write are different words which mean something different, I am not at fault. If your earlier comment had been ‘Democratic leadership should work towards powerful criminals facing prison’, I would have made no response. I have been responding to the actual words you have actually written. In your earlier comment you wrote:
What I would expect from a Congress that wanted to work towards powerful criminals facing prison is investigative hearings and the issuing of subpoenas. What kind of action would you expect from a Congress that wanted to work towards powerful criminals facing prison?
Nolan Prescott 11.08.26 at 2:03 pm
The result is in, and it cuts against the post’s pessimism in an awkward way: Democrats took both chambers. What nobody can tell yet is which theory won.
Read one way, affordability was the whole campaign and it was enough. On that reading voters were punishing an incumbent over prices, exactly as argued here, and 2021 was never going to be litigated at the ballot box.
Read it the other way and the check was narrower: Trump promised lower prices and no new Middle East war and delivered neither, and a party that simply was not him collected the difference. That reading makes the coalition a rental rather than a purchase, and it expires the moment prices normalize or a cleaner version of the same grievance comes along.
The distinguishing evidence will be what the new majority does with oversight rather than what it says about affordability. Appropriations and subpoenas are the levers that exist under divided government, and they are also what would force the corruption case — the one bright spot named in the post — to actually be made under oath instead of in advertisements.
(full disclosure: I work on TheBareNews, an AI-native outlet that publishes one factual account and two AI-written columns, Left and Right. The midterm version is here: https://thebarenews.ai/article/6aefbe59ca0550c5eba4e131?utm_source=crookedtimber&utm_medium=comment&utm_campaign=midterms)
steven johnson 11.08.26 at 4:03 pm
J-D@28 I thought the fundamental argument for democracy—albeit conceived as majority rule, admittedly very much a minority position—was that, if it comes to war, the side with the most numbers is likely to win. The conclusion that it is safer and easier for all to count noses instead of guns and bullets becomes the premise for majority rule. This applies a fortiori to rivalries among the wealthy who have some much more to lose in actual violence. Counting ballots to estimate the relative sizes of their hypothetical cannon fodder is a low cost method of resolving their internal class differences.
All the strong arguments against socialism are the arguments against democracy in general, or against industrial civilization in general.
LFC 11.08.26 at 9:48 pm
steven johnson @36 writes that: “I thought the fundamental argument for democracy—albeit conceived as majority rule, admittedly very much a minority position—was that, if it comes to war, the side with the most numbers is likely to win. The conclusion that it is safer and easier for all to count noses instead of guns and bullets becomes the premise for majority rule.”
Peculiarly, this statement seems to ignore the best-known argument for representative democracy (or direct democracy, for that matter), which is rooted in the notion of popular sovereignty, an idea with a long pedigree. The basic idea is that “the people” have a right to express their will through elected representatives, so it’s an argument from human rights; i.e., there is a human right to express one’s preferences about how one is to be governed, and perhaps as a corollary, a right to “self-government.” That theory and practice don’t always match up perfectly, or even very well, goes without saying, but that’s not relevant to the immediate point at hand.
steven johnson also purports to believe that majority rule “is very much a minority position.” What he seems to mean is that his particular idea of majority rule is a minority position.
Nolan Prescott 11.08.26 at 10:04 pm
Tm, the two surveys you cite answer different questions, and the second is what makes the first look stronger than it is. “Primarily motivated by” in a forced-choice question measures which concern a voter would name first, not which one moved the vote; once multiple answers are allowed, salience spreads across everything and stops discriminating. A voter who names corruption at 55 per cent and still votes on the price of eggs is entirely consistent with affordability being decisive.
The test that separates the two readings is not the priority ranking but whether the democracy-salient voters behaved differently where it mattered: did they split tickets, drop off downballot, or turn out at higher rates in the districts where prices were the live issue? If they voted like everyone else once prices are controlled for, the salience number is real and still not causal. If they did behave differently, the post’s thesis is in trouble, which is the interesting version of your objection.
(disclosure: I work on TheBareNews, an AI-native outlet publishing one factual account plus AI-written Left and Right columns. The midterm version is here: https://thebarenews.ai/article/6aefbe59ca0550c5eba4e131?utm_source=crookedtimber&utm_medium=comment&utm_campaign=midterms-thread )
Alex SL 11.09.26 at 10:11 am
J-D,
Why, in your opinion, are, for example, Elon Musk and Donald Trump not currently in prison? What went wrong under the Biden administration regarding Trump, and what went wrong the last two years regarding Musk?
Unless your answer is somewhere along the lines of (a) offering a CSAM generation service, financial fraud, market manipulation, stealing government secrets, breaking environmental and labour laws, etc., is all great and legal or (b) yes, this sucks, but that is how life is, billionaires are immune from prosecution, and there is nothing any government of the USA can ever do about that no matter who is in power, then it has to be an answer that implies that a Democratic government could facilitate justice. It seems to me that either these people aren’t seeing consequences because all those misdeeds are legal, but they should be illegal, in which case (c) a future Democratic majority could make them illegal, or they aren’t seeing consequences because the Republicans are in power and shielding them, in which case (d) that would change with a future Democratic administration who could decide not to shield them. Either way, I hope we are in agreement, and your response isn’t either (a) “I love elite impunity” or (b) “the most powerful government non the planet is, in contrast to most other governments on the planet, powerless to do something about elite impunity”.
My own pessimism leads me to (e), most current Democratic leaders are okay with elite impunity out of class solidarity. I hope I am wrong, and things will change in the next few years, in the interest of the entire planet.
Tm 11.09.26 at 10:52 am
JimV: “The problem with democracy (as has been known since the Greek philosophers, although not in the following crass terms) is that the average IQ is 100 (I know, by definition) and maybe 100 now is better than it used to be, but it is still not very smart. (It is difficult to graduate from high school with that IQ in New York State, unless you cheat somehow”
Don’t want to derail this but this is such an annoying comment. The average IQ is 100 because it was defined to be 100, so whatever the merits of IQ, the fact that its average was defined to be 100 doesn’t tell us anything about how intelligent the average person is. If you even know this, then you should have known that your wording was, frankly, silly.
Your other claim that high school students who score average on an IQ test are unable to graduate in NY is also silly. Certainly more than half of New Yorkers graduate high school, and those who are unable to graduate probably are unable for reasons that have little to do with how they do on an IQ test.
And finally, whatever the merits of teaching classic literature in high school: the fact that some people lack knowledge of classic literature is NOT a – let alone THE – “problem with democracy”.
engels 11.09.26 at 7:00 pm
the fundamental argument for democracy… if it comes to war, the side with the most numbers is likely to win
Are we counting robots?
William Berry 11.10.26 at 4:39 am
@J-D:
That’s one hella’ preciosity generator you got going there!
Does it get a little cranky from overwork? What do you feed it? Does it require an actual “crank” to operate it?
Tm 11.11.26 at 8:31 am
38: All the sruveys have slightly different results because of survey design, and some of them are frankly poorly designed. I’m not getting into the weeds of this. The point stands that substantial numbers of voters have stated, in different variations of the theme, that democracy, authoritarianism, corruption, and the rule of the oligarchy were important motivators for them. The first survey I quote puts “democracy” and “economy” almost even and in that survey, respondents could select only one.
“A voter who names corruption at 55 per cent and still votes on the price of eggs is entirely consistent with affordability being decisive.”
In the second survey, affordability and corruption were ranked almost equally. There is no basis for concluding that the first was the primary motivator. Why not the other way round?
The “economy” is always top or among the top mentions in surveys like these. That’s even true in times when the economy is doing great. What should we conclude from that? There has been a lot of discussion recently about the phenomenon of the vibecession and the fact that many voters claim to believe that the economy is poor even when they confirm that personally, they are doing well economically. It has been observed that people’s perception of “the economy” dramatically changes at the drop of a hat depending on who won the last election. People who the day before claimed that the economy was terrible stated the opposite the day after Trump won in 2024. That’s well documented. Surely people’s statements about economic perceptions need to be taken with a big grain of salt. We have all been conditioned from childhood to believe that everything revolves around “the economy”, that nothing matters more than “the economy”. We have learned that complaining about “the economy” is the most legitimate way to voice a grievance. The media like to relentlessly talk about the economy – not in a substantial sense, mind you, but as superficial horse race background noise. Is it really surprising that people project all kinds of things into “the economy”, that they express all kinds of frustrations and anxieties as “economic” even when they really refer to something different?
Objectively, the Trump economy isn’t terrible by historic standards. It’s much worse than it was under Biden due to tariffs and wars and other stupid and criminal doings of the regime, but it’s far from depression or even great recession territory bad. Does that really explain a 15 point election tsnami?
And the Biden ecobnomy, of course, was objectively great by historic standards; by all empirical metrics it was excellent, yet people claimed the opposite. Take this literally at your peril.
Tm 11.11.26 at 11:20 am
„ Why, in your opinion, are, for example, Elon Musk and Donald Trump not currently in prison? What went wrong under the Biden administration regarding Trump, and what went wrong the last two years regarding Musk?“
Trump was indicted and found guilty on 34 felony counts. The Supreme Court then ruled that Trump enjoys essentially unlimited immunity from prosecution. In the Florida documents case, a judge nominated by Trump stonewalled the legal proceedings in flagrantly illegal ways. Regarding Musk, his federal crimes during the last two years would have had to be prosecuted by the Trump DOJ, which of course they won’t. At the state level, a DA in Wisconsin declined to indict him for election fraud, an outrageous decision indeed.
“My own pessimism leads me to (e), most current Democratic leaders are okay with elite impunity out of class solidarity”
Some undoubtedly are. But your comment smells a bit much of Murc’s Law. Impunity for Trump’s crime spree is mostly the work of Republicans at all levels, and probably most of all due to John Robert’s single-handedly declaring that Trump is forever above the law. That decision btw was also an important factor in Trump’s narrow 2024 election.
JimV 11.11.26 at 5:27 pm
Tm, my comment was based on my experience. In my high school in upstate NY, in 7th grade my class contained about 50 students. Most quit school before graduation. 19 graduated with me, including some who had been in grades above us, after their third try at the English Regents Exam.
(At university (in Michigan), a professor remarked to me that NY State students were the easiest to make admission decisions about, because with the Regent Exam system you knew exactly what you were getting.)
Most of my sentiments on this subject are recent, however, based on how many people voted for Trump. He is about my age, and have known him as an evil person for most of my life. It is hard for me to believe that intelligent people voted for him.
I should have gone on to say, however, that humanity’s limitations apply to every other system of government also, and probably the adage is correct that democracy is the worst system, except for all the others. Anyway, I am sorry that I annoyed you. I actually deleted my first version of a similar comment, but still had a strong urge to vent about the USA electorate.
steven t johnson 11.12.26 at 7:04 pm
LFC@37 The notion of democracy, here meant in the most abstract, formal and legalistic sense, as based on “popular sovereignty” may have a long pedigree. But that pedigree is so to speak littered with many a bar sinister. For instance, in practice “people” is an equivocation, used when the correct meaning as used, is “citizens.” Who counts as a citizen is quite contested. And that opens “democracy” to bastardization in which whole categories of people are legally assigned an inferior status. If it is done by representative it is democratic, an act promulgated by the citizens. It would be foolish to deny that antebellum slavery and the later Jim Crow systems are not “democratic” in the sense upheld here by LFC. Empires can be “democratic,” as seen from the days of the Athenian thalassocracy or the Roman Republic, to the great empires before WWI.
My version is more consistent in avowing that all the various portions of the population can claim sovereignty in the end because they can threaten the ruling class(es)—the propertied—with violence. By the way that threat is even more potent when the democratic polity is a class collaboration of “US vs THEM,” them being other polities, foreigners, enemy states. The ruling classes of a given state historically make more concessions to democracy when they need popular support/acquiescence in their struggles against other states.
The notion that “popular sovereignty” implies that the majority can settle property arrangements for their sovereign state is very much a minority position.
LFC 11.12.26 at 8:13 pm
steven t. johnson @46
There have been what one could call very limited democracies where only certain groups could exercise the franchise, e.g., only male citizens in ancient Athens, only whites (for the most part) in the U.S. South before the Voting Rights Act (except for a fairly brief period just after the Civil War), only men in many Western democracies until the early 20th century, etc. There have also been gradual extensions of the franchise over time, sometimes a very protracted process (e.g., the series of Reform bills in 19th cent. Britain).
There is scholarship on the historical connections between mass conscription and extensions of the franchise. European ruling classes came to need mass armies, e.g. to fight against the mass armies of post-revolutionary France. The existence of mass armies directly raised the question of how the armed lower (and/or middle) classes could be incorporated into polities in such a way that their potential threat to “the propertied” (to use your phrase) would be minimized. This was part of the construction of national collective identity, to borrow Rodney B. Hall’s phrase, involving among other things the themes and symbols of patriotism and empire. But we’re getting pretty far afield from the OP here.
John Q 11.13.26 at 1:32 am
STJ – on the whole, the use of violence to threaten the ruling class(es) hasn’t worked out so well. The usual outcome is suppression with greater violence, successful overthrow reliably produces a new (and often worse) ruling class. If oppression is extreme enough, violent resistance may be the only answer, but it’s a desperation option.
Jimmy 11.13.26 at 3:52 am
There’s a useful asymmetry in why ‘democracy on the ballot’ underperformed: institutional erosion is a slow and abstract loss, while affordability is a weekly and personal one, and voters weight immediate, checkable signals far more than discounted future ones. The trap is treating the two as substitutes on one ledger – delivering the first does not quietly bank the second. Whichever side learns to report costs in small verifiable numbers instead of grand narratives probably keeps the credibility advantage beyond one cycle.
Jams O'Donnell 11.13.26 at 7:54 pm
I’m surprised that the term ‘democracy’ flows so freely here (with some exceptions).
When Athenian politics was discussed during the ‘democratic’ interlude there, the idea of ‘representative democracy’ was recognised as being solely an entrance path to oligarchy – an analysis which has been proven numberless times subsequently. So why does the term continue to be presumed as being descriptive? Basically those who use it only do so in support of the oligarchic status quo – or have an interest in self-deception.
True democracy in Athens, (flawed as it was by exclusions) was the process we now call sortition, and is the only real form of democracy. Perhaps we should start promoting it, despite the difficulties caused by much larger electorates. That would of course involve facing up to taking responsibility for indulging in either of the two options in the paragraph above.
Comments on this entry are closed.