I like the direction this is going in.

by Michael Bérubé on December 5, 2009

How to follow up a sublime and funky thread that has established four new internet traditions and killed at least two performers of Franz Schubert’s tempestuous piano Sonata No. 21 in B flat (D.960)?

By having <a href=”http://www.mcsweeneys.net/2009/11/20quatro.html”>Catherine and Heathcliff audition for <i>Twilight</i></a>, that’s how.

{ 31 comments }

1

Jeffrey Daniel Rubard 12.05.09 at 5:28 pm

That’s hellaciously funny, Michael; and the unfunny part is the “o’course” which implies no Fool of Keyboard Borne can be harmed, even by yo’ own coke, which is a la someone “just not true” in a sense *I* will pree-cisify. You, Berube, are *neither* Foxy (to?) Brown, Greil Marcus made good, or all up in my bizness on occasion; just a “sharper” that clews those who have the blews non I’M FROM NY AND CONSEQUENTLY AWESOME — a story untold, true but unknown *by me*, and really the advice is to stop wasting people’s time with dangeroids like this.

2

rm 12.05.09 at 6:04 pm

You know, I really did think of Twilight right away when you made that aside about how Wuthering Heights is not actually “romantic” in the non-capitalized sense. I think your using the word “creepy” was probably an intentional feint, in your overdeterminedly allusive style, toward a discussioin of Twilight, and I thought of pulling that out into the open then. But, you know, off topic.

And the wisdom of not saying anything is confirmed, because that link does it so much better. Hilarious.

3

Cosma Shalizi 12.05.09 at 6:04 pm

Those truly devoted to Internet Traditions know that everything is better with lolcats, even Twilight and New Moon

4

Delicious Pundit 12.05.09 at 7:31 pm

My favorite Wuthering Heights-related humor is still Ian Frazier’s “Linton’s Whatnots,” about Edgar’s nutcracker collection:

“Soon I heard from the room above me the faint sounds of her departure. I could imagine the passion of their meeting, her caresses more intense for the tiresome half hour I had made her endure. I filled the lamp with coal oil, the costlier, smokeless kind, and prepared for an evening of cataloguing.”

5

kid bitzer 12.05.09 at 7:53 pm

that is brilliant, and also depressing. we used to be so much better with evil.

i can’t tell whether this shows that our decadence has degenerated, or that our degeneracy has decayed. anyhow, there’s been a real falling-off in our fallen state.

6

christian h. 12.05.09 at 8:05 pm

Michael, thanks for posting that link. It reminds me why – and I’m not afraid to admit it – Wuthering Heights is one of my favourite novels.

7

Michael Bérubé 12.05.09 at 8:23 pm

Anytime, Christian. And while I’m complaining about the domestication of this novel, I’d just like to add that I am good and tired of people whitening Heathcliff. Really. Dark and brooding and somewhat Irish just doesn’t get at it.

So far as I can see, only one production even came close.

8

Michael Bérubé 12.05.09 at 8:29 pm

Cosma: Those truly devoted to Internet Traditions know that everything is better with lolcats, even Twilight and New Moon.

You didn’t prepare me for the total triple-threat awesomeness of the final panel on the second link. That is some major internet-tradition awesomeness by any measure.

9

Hortense 12.05.09 at 8:33 pm

Twilight parody with glitter –

Sparkledammerung.

10

Salient 12.05.09 at 8:41 pm

Dammit MB, I was about to say “six comments in and this thread is already killing me with the awesome” and now it would just look derivative. Anyway:

I’d just like to add that I am good and tired of people whitening Heathcliff.

I feel the same way about Jesus.

(But no, folks, we do not want to envision Catherine and Heathcliff auditioning for the roles of Magdalene and X in Passion of the Christ. Do. Not. Want. That is emphatically not the direction this is going in.)

11

Michael Bérubé 12.05.09 at 8:52 pm

You think this thread is awesome now, Salient. But ten years from now, I bet you’re going to regret it.

Except for the three-wolf-moon part. That stuff is forever.

12

Salient 12.05.09 at 9:24 pm

But ten years from now, I bet you’re going to regret it.

Bah, I don’t know who I was kidding there, ten years from now I’ll be waiting in line at Panera and my 7-year-old daughter Elizabeth will be fidgety and my wife will turn and say, “look, it’s a long line, can we just go somewhere else?” and I will say, if only to myself, and possibly with more resignation than verve: Like Mr. 137 and Cassie Wright’s relationship in Chuck Palahniuk’s remarkable novel Snuff or Beck David Campbell’s tempestuous vinyl single Devil’s Haircut (ASIN B000000OOY), I will not let wife or Beth stand in the way of this sublime and funky Chocolate Duet cookie (net wt 2.75 oz (78g)) that I crave!

13

Michael Bérubé 12.05.09 at 11:11 pm

So you’ve definitely decided on the name Elizabeth, then, and for that very reason. Good call!

14

Salient 12.05.09 at 11:19 pm

Just wait ’til my kid finds out her name was chosen to rhyme with ‘death.’ It’s on par with naming my firstborn son Sue: “But Daaaaad, it wasn’t even original!”

15

jacob 12.06.09 at 1:45 am

Salient, you aren’t actually Randall Munroe, are you? That last comment was dead on for one of the alt-text comments.

16

Ricardo Glèbe 12.06.09 at 4:19 am

Up until now, I had always wondered what they meant by “arch.”

17

Daniel Wolf 12.06.09 at 10:53 am

While, as a musician, I may well be missing something in the Wuthering angle, the Sonata in Bb has definitely always been considered sublime, funky, and tempestuous. This is due in part to Schubert’s profligate use of mediant and semitonal functional harmonic relations (the most familiar is probably the lowered submediant in the opening of the first movement), to the unorthodox tonal layout of the movements (the second movement is in c# minor), as well as to the references to some of the composer’s own songs and perhaps even Schubert’s autobiographic story Mein Traum. But most of all, the work (like all three late sonatas) invests its constrasting elements of statis, continuity, and sudden shifts in tonality held together by cyclic elements in holding a thread — and perhaps a narrative thread at that — throughout the work. The tempestuous journey taken by that thread makes it abundantly clear that Schubert had his funky on.

18

Michael Bérubé 12.06.09 at 6:46 pm

Ah, I see that this thread has a whole new beginning: apparently Mr. Rubard’s comment had been in moderation for some reason. I presume he was trying to out-absurd that other thread in just one go, with extra extra “jazz” stylings for flavor.

19

Doctor Science 12.06.09 at 7:31 pm

The Sparkledammerung posts are not just parody, they are the best explication yet of the Mormon elements in the Twilight series. The combination of mockery + literary/critical exegesis + deliberately bad Photoshop + religious/social insights = THE FUTURE OF CULTURE CRIT. Take notes, Michael. If you can do this for “The Rise of Silas Lapham”, the world will be the mollusc of your choice.

20

Bill Benzon 12.06.09 at 7:44 pm

@1: sublimerrific and funkalicious, cubed

21

Michael Bérubé 12.06.09 at 7:57 pm

If you can do this for “The Rise of Silas Lapham”, the world will be the mollusc of your choice.

I think this is all I need to persuade Norton to publish a second edition of What’s Liberal. Kthxbai!

Bill, as you probably remember from that MySpace pileup of 2004, references to “cubing” are potentially offensive to mathematicians. Though in fairness I’ll admit that Rubard started it with that “o’course” remark. Unfunny, indeed.

22

Doctor Science 12.06.09 at 8:18 pm

I can’t wait to see the bad Photoshop version of “Silas Lapham”, presumably in the style of Wondermark.

23

Bill Benzon 12.06.09 at 9:50 pm

Yeah, I remember that Michael. But didn’t the mathematicians get embroiled in a beef with the Butcher’s International Benevolent Association and the Bouillon Brewers Cooperative over who had rights to the cube offense?

In any event, I believe christian h is a mathematician. We could hook him up to an Official Internets Offense-0-Meter and see whether or not he rings the bell on that one. If so, I’ll donate a copy of Brother West to the Bourbaki Home for Imaginary Maths.

24

Michael Bérubé 12.06.09 at 10:05 pm

didn’t the mathematicians get embroiled in a beef with the Butcher’s International Benevolent Association and the Bouillon Brewers Cooperative over who had rights to the cube offense?

Yes, yes they did, but I find this characterization of that blogspat to be carnicentric (a “beef,” indeed) because it overlooks the entirely legitimate complaints of the cheesemakers. Or was it dairy producers in general?

25

Bill Benzon 12.06.09 at 10:26 pm

The Fondue Foundation? After all, you always were such a cheeze wiz, Michael.

26

rm 12.07.09 at 4:57 am

Alas, robbed of first by an Ezra-Hound-bot.

27

Kenny Easwaran 12.07.09 at 6:51 am

I always found the funky and sublime aspect of that Schubert sonata to be the triplets against dotted eighth note rhythms. Assuming I’m thinking of the correct Schubert sonata in B-flat.

28

Michael Bérubé 12.07.09 at 1:17 pm

The triplets against the dotted eighths would be Shubert’s “Doin’ it to Death,” especially the part where he tells the band they got to get in D.

29

christian h. 12.07.09 at 6:37 pm

Sorry Bill but my offense-o-meter is broken. Cube away, if that’s your thing. Michael, on the other hand, clearly is a square.

30

christian h. 12.07.09 at 6:39 pm

Dang in moderation again… this makes it impossible to participate in this highly enlightening conversation.

31

Michael Bérubé 12.07.09 at 9:29 pm

You were not in moderation. Your comment was being cubed.

Comments on this entry are closed.