Comment spam, me? Ha! This must be one of your human jokes!

by John Holbo on April 8, 2005

Do you know what’s interesting about comment spam? Nothing, of course. But consider this. No piece of comment spam has ever been able to mimic a human convincingly. It tries, but comment spam is like the aliens among us. They look like us, dress like us … but they also eat the houseplants. In obedience to the iron genre trope that there must be some obvious failure of mimicry that gives away this sinister presence. To read comment spam is to come to awareness that these creatures have travelled a long way to get to our little blue marble floating in space (whether they come in peace, or to breed with the ladies, or because their home planet is tragically polluted.) Consider this offering, left in response to a post about a passage from Thomas Mann:

I also have read some of the best articles I’ve ever read after coming into the blogoshpere. I check the indices such as Daypop for what are the most linked news stories and blogs. I used to go to the library and look through publications but I would never find the articles and stories I’m finding on the internet.

There is a pathos to it. (I’ve left it up to reward it for winning my heart.) I’m seeing an alien who has assumed a somewhat Walter Mittyish form. He is short with thick glasses. His suit is ill-fitting. Every day he goes to the library seeking information about this strange new world. The nice librarian – a mousy girl with glasses and pearls – very demurely executes a gesture that takes in a whole room of books full of articles and stories. Our protagonist clumsily examines a few volumes, sniffs them, turns them upside down. Where is the information? When he becomes frustrated he makes little honking noises that annoy a bosomy old blue-haired bluenose society-type. A rugged teenage boy in his proud letterman’s jacket is checking out a book on football. He openly laughs at the stranger. “Yer an oddball, fella,” causing the little man to back nervously against the shelves, eyes darting. A book falls on his head. The librarian, feeling sorry for him, whispers ‘shhhh’. Every day it is the same until one day the delivery man, polite cap in hand, presents the librarian with the heavy box containing the library’s new computer. She is nervous but excited, eager to make this new thing part of her little domain. She isn’t sure how it works … but the mysterious stranger is there by her side. Somehow his fingers find all the right keys. We see the light of scrolling pages reflected in the lenses of glasses. Daypop! He is happy. The light is in her glasses, too. She is happy, seeing that he is happy. Every day he is there, always Daypop sending him to new blogs where he leaves messages. Always the same. About how in the library he could never find anything, but now Daypop sends him to new blogs everyday. He can hardly type the messages quickly enough. (He has another amusing tick. He always drinks milk. Only milk. Which gives him a silly moustache. But the milk makes him slightly drunk – his alien metabolism. Hence he slurs his speech and types things like ‘blogoshpere’.) One day the librarian, out of curiosity, clicks on the little hyperlink that is his name – odd name, sounds foreign – at the bottom of one of those many comments he leaves all day, every day. It transports her to … the little stranger’s homeworld, where she is surrounded by golden (oh, hell with it.)

{ 1 trackback }

Crooked Timber » » Origins Bomb
07.19.05 at 8:51 am

{ 19 comments }

1

Doug 04.08.05 at 9:45 am

Pnin!

2

Simstim 04.08.05 at 10:11 am

You know, for a moment I thought this was a post by John Holbo, but you alien scum forgot one small thing: it’s not long enough!

3

ProfWombat 04.08.05 at 10:21 am

Coals to Newcastle, bringing me in on a tertiary when you’re here, Mitty. Topaka topaka topaka…

4

PZ Myers 04.08.05 at 10:44 am

No piece of comment spam has ever been able to mimic a human convincingly.

How do you know this? If it were a comment able to mimic the output of a human, you wouldn’t recognize it as spam. If, for instance, someone left a message with the sole intent of introducing a link to his website, it would be spam, but if you thought it was a serious comment meant to introduce a legitimate point, you wouldn’t score it as such.

5

novalis 04.08.05 at 10:45 am

As the always brilliant Rebecca Borgstrom wrote, “the noise dreams of signal”.

6

Ted 04.08.05 at 11:28 am

This post is an obvious forgery. As is this comment.

7

todd. 04.08.05 at 12:10 pm

Sounds strikingly like Mr. Mee (a novel I read on the recommendation of someone at CT; thanks for that, by the way).

8

walter 04.08.05 at 12:20 pm

I also have read some of the best articles I’ve ever read after coming into the blogoshpere. I check the indices such as Daypop for what are the most linked news stories and blogs. I used to go to the library and look through publications but I would never find the articles and stories I’m finding on the internet.

9

HP 04.08.05 at 12:34 pm

I thought at first that this post might end with “…and I’m all out of bubble-gum,” but you took it in an entirely different direction.

10

Barry Freed 04.08.05 at 1:27 pm

Perhaps the Turing test will be passed one day by a pr0n or viagra spammer.

And I was sorely tempted to write:

Great post. Nice blog. There’s some really good writing on this blog. Someday I hope to have a blog like this but it seems like a lot of hard work.

[ obscene URL here: even joke spam gets moderated, though :) ]

The thing I find most annoying about the comment spam (other than its profusion- tell Prof. Froomkin to get a better filter please) is how insulting it is to our intelligence.

11

Jeremy Osner 04.08.05 at 1:33 pm

Wow Novalis, thanks for that marvellous link — I had been to Hitherby Dragons before but had forgotten about it.

12

Phil 04.08.05 at 3:23 pm

surrounded by golden…enlarged penises? Just asking.

13

Barry Freed 04.08.05 at 3:52 pm

[ obscene URL here: even joke spam gets moderated, though :) ]

Jeebus H. Cripes! Are you saying that was a real live URL? I didn’t even think of checking it. I thought I had just pulled it out of my…uh…head.

(I based the youwant part on a particularly obscene flurry of such spams that hit the Poorman a while back.)

14

theogon 04.08.05 at 10:25 pm

“Novalis” is an obvious spammer. Anybody actually posting in the comments section of a blog is a Nybaasite trying to fulfill their dissonance conditions the quick way.

15

Gil 04.09.05 at 1:28 am

Is comment spam really trying to fool people, or just automated filters?

I suspect that enough people click on their links even though they know it’s automated spam to make it worth the almost zero cost of creating it.

Just like email spam.

16

Danny Yee 04.09.05 at 2:22 am

Why is this post not comment spam?

17

John Holbo 04.09.05 at 5:28 am

Thanks so much, Novalis, for the Hitherby link. That’s great. (Come to think of it, I can’t imagine how I neglected to finish the story by characterizing the alien world as inhabited by creatures just like us, only the males have penises 3-inches longer than ours.)

18

novalis 04.11.05 at 2:42 pm

John, I thought it would be your sort of thing. My other favorite non-plot-arc entries are “Rainbow Noir”, “Once Upon a Time, There Was…”, and the very silly “Why Don’t Ducks Have Hides?”

The best opening lines are likely from “Morpheus Explains The Qaballah”

The best title is “Aslan Shrugged”, which manages to simultaneously attack Ayn Rand and C.S. Lewis in two words.

19

Matt Weiner 04.11.05 at 3:55 pm

The original comment was deleted, but “Good and articulate points” snuck by the Unfoggeders for a while. Then it got turned into what Unfogged comments get turned into.

Comments on this entry are closed.